AI Search

How to Compare Sources in Google AI Mode, ChatGPT Search, and Perplexity

Use one question and a side-by-side worksheet to compare brand mentions, visible links, and source types across three AI search platforms.

Three search paths converging on a stack of documents.

Key takeaways

  • Use the same question and record the conditions for each platform comparison.

  • Separate named brands from visible linked URLs; they are different observations.

  • Google requires indexing and snippet eligibility for a page to be considered as an AI Mode supporting link.

  • OpenAI and Perplexity document separate search crawlers and user-requested fetchers).

To compare AI search sources, ask the same question in Google AI Mode, ChatGPT Search, and Perplexity. For each answer, record the brands named, the links visible to you, and the type of page behind each link. Then compare the results at both the domain and individual URL level.

Treat the comparison as a record of what you observed, not a definitive ranking. Google says AI Mode can issue multiple related searches and provide links to supporting websites; the links it shows can vary (source 1).

Set up a consistent comparison

  1. Choose one question. Use the exact same wording on all three platforms. A hypothetical prompt such as “How should a team compare content management systems?” is suitable; it is a test question, not an observed result.

  2. Record the conditions. Note the date, time, country, language, account or access context, and any platform settings you used. If you cannot establish a setting, mark it unknown.

  3. Capture each answer. Save the answer text or a screenshot, and record the visible links you can inspect. Note whether you expanded any source lists or link groups.

  4. Keep the first pass separate from follow-ups. If you ask a follow-up, record it as a separate observation rather than adding its sources to the initial answer.

The supplied platform documentation describes site access and crawler behavior, but does not establish current steps or eligibility for opening each consumer search experience. Check the platforms’ current access guidance before running or publishing your comparison.

Side-by-side AI search sources worksheet

Copy this blank worksheet for each question. Record only what you can see; use “not observed” rather than assuming an absent mention or link cannot appear in another run.

Field

Google AI Mode

ChatGPT Search

Perplexity

Exact question

Enter question

Enter same question

Enter same question

Date, time and context

Record

Record

Record

Named brands

List names or “not observed”

List names or “not observed”

List names or “not observed”

Visible linked URLs

List URLs

List URLs

List URLs

Source types

Classify each linked page

Classify each linked page

Classify each linked page

Link location and inspection notes

Record

Record

Record

For longer answers, use a separate row for every visible link. Include the platform, URL, domain, page title, source type, and where the link appeared. If the same URL appears more than once, record its locations and decide whether your count is of unique URLs or link appearances.

Classify sources consistently

Open each link where possible and assign a category based on the page itself. Useful working categories include official vendor documentation, a vendor product page, an independent editorial or comparison page, a forum or community page, and research or institutional material. Add “other” or “unknown” when a page does not fit or cannot be inspected. These are worksheet categories, not platform-provided labels.

Keep brand mentions separate from linked sources: a brand named in the answer is not automatically a linked source, and a linked domain is not automatically a brand recommendation.

Read the comparison

  • Look for shared URLs and domains. A shared domain with different linked pages can point to different material being surfaced. Check the actual URLs before treating the sources as identical.

  • Compare source types. Note whether the visible links include official documentation, independent comparisons, or other categories. Inspect the pages before drawing conclusions about their content.

  • Compare mentions with links. Record whether a named brand also has a visible link to its own site. Do not treat either observation alone as proof of a recommendation or visit.

  • Document gaps. Separate “not observed” from “could not inspect.” A missing observation in one answer is not proof that a platform never uses that source.

  • Repeat deliberately. Run the same question again as a separate observation and preserve the conditions and results for each run. Avoid combining counts without stating what each count measures.

Blank source cards arranged for comparison under a magnifying glass.
Compare individual pages as well as the domains that publish them.

Check whether your own site is accessible

Source comparison can reveal where to investigate, but it cannot by itself establish why a page was or was not linked. Use the platforms’ official site-owner guidance to check access.

Google AI Mode

Google says a page must be indexed and eligible to appear in Google Search with a snippet to be eligible as a supporting link in AI Mode. It specifies no additional technical requirements for AI features. Check crawling, internal links, and whether important content is available as text; use Search Console to help diagnose technical issues (source 1).

Eligibility is not a guarantee that a particular answer will link to the page. Google also reports AI-feature traffic within overall Search Console performance under the Web search type, rather than as a separate AI Mode report in the supplied guidance (source 1).

OpenAI identifies OAI-SearchBot as its search crawler and recommends allowing it in robots.txt and permitting requests from its published IP ranges. Sites opted out of OAI-SearchBot will not be shown in ChatGPT search answers, though they can still appear as navigational links (source 2).

OAI-SearchBot and GPTBot settings are independent: GPTBot concerns content that may be used for training. ChatGPT-User is a separate agent for certain user-initiated actions, and OpenAI says robots.txt rules may not apply to those actions (source 2).

Perplexity

Perplexity recommends allowing PerplexityBot in robots.txt and permitting its published IP ranges for search-result access. It describes PerplexityBot as a search crawler, not a crawler for AI foundation models (source 3).

Perplexity-User handles user-requested page fetches and generally ignores robots.txt. If a firewall blocks access, review Perplexity’s guidance for matching each bot’s user agent with its own published IP ranges; check current ranges before changing a rule (source 3).

Prepare your source comparison

  • Choose one question and copy its exact wording into the worksheet.

  • Record the date, context, and any source lists you expanded on each platform.

  • Log each visible URL and classify its page type after inspection.

  • Compare shared domains and individual URLs without conflating them.

  • Investigate relevant indexing, crawler, and firewall settings using current official guidance.

FAQs

Does Google require special markup for a page to appear in AI Mode?

Google says there are no additional technical requirements for AI features. A supporting page must be indexed and eligible to appear in Google Search with a snippet; Google also recommends that structured data match visible page text (source 1).

Can I allow ChatGPT Search without allowing GPTBot?

OpenAI says the OAI-SearchBot and GPTBot settings are independent. A site owner can allow OAI-SearchBot for search while disallowing GPTBot to indicate that crawled content should not be used for training OpenAI’s generative AI foundation models (source 2).

Is PerplexityBot used to crawl content for AI foundation models?

Perplexity says PerplexityBot is designed to surface and link websites in its search results and is not used to crawl content for AI foundation models (source 3).

Can Search Console isolate AI Mode traffic in the supplied guidance?

Google says appearances in its AI features are included in overall Search Console performance reporting under the Web search type. The supplied guidance does not describe a separate AI Mode report (source 1).

Sources

  1. AI Features and Your Website | Google Search Central | Documentation | Google for DevelopersAccessed
  2. Overview of OpenAI CrawlersAccessed
  3. Perplexity Crawlers - PerplexityAccessed

Discussion

Join the discussion

Start the conversation

Share a question or tell us what worked for you.

Comments appear after review. How we handle comments

The Ansvra journal

Keep reading

Browse all articles

Measure AI shopping by task

Separate discovery, purchasing and service questions using Salesforce’s historical shopper survey, complete response tables and a practical AI visibility review workflow.

Ansvra

A clearer next step.

MEET YOUR AI GUIDE

A little clarity.
A clearer next move.

Ask about Ansvra, AI visibility, or your next step with content.

Opening chat…